PlayDecoded

St. Louis Cardinals at Pittsburgh Pirates

Pittsburgh Pirates vs St. Louis Cardinals head-to-head

MLBregular • 2026 Season
completed
Pirates logo
Pirates
Pittsburgh
1
vs
Cardinals logo
Cardinals
St. Louis
5

PIT 56%, STL 44%. The model favors PIT.

PIT 56%44% STL
Prediction confidence
Medium

Pittsburgh Pirates 56% to win. The top 2 signals favoring Pirates:

  • Home field. Base home field advantage applied (no detailed stats available)
  • Team rating. Pirates ELO 1519 vs Cardinals ELO 1471 (diff: +48)

What would change the call

Win probability as of kickoff if a leading factor were even

  • If the home-field advantage were neutral: PIT 52% (−4)

Win probability movement

PIT home win probability as the model updated before the game

Home win probability movement61%56%51%Sep 23Sep 23

Labels mark updates of 5 points or more. Every move has a stored reason below.

Why it moved

  • no input change recordedShow breakdown
    • no input change recorded

Make Your Prediction

View leaderboard to see rankings

Date & Time
Wednesday, September 23, 2026
Wed, Sep 23, 6:40 PM ET
VenuePNC Park
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Team Comparison

Head-to-head snapshot based on our model inputs

Cardinals (away)
Pirates (home)
44%
Win probability
56%
0
High-impact factors
0
0
Out or on IR
0

Post-Game Analysis

How our model performed

The Cardinals defeated the Pirates 5-1.

Our model predicted the Pirates would win with 56% confidence, but the Cardinals pulled off the upset. These outcomes are what keep sports compelling -- and help our model learn.

Looking at the factors our model weighed:

  • Home Field Advantage favored the Pirates and was a notable factor: Base home field advantage applied (no detailed stats available)
  • Rest Days was neutral and a contributing factor: Similar rest: Pirates (1 day rest) vs Cardinals (1 day rest)
  • Weather Impact was neutral and a contributing factor: Weather data not available

This analysis was generated from our model's pre-game assessment compared against the actual result. Factor accuracy helps improve future predictions.

Cardinals won 1-5

Cardinals won by a solid margin

Prediction IncorrectWe predicted Pirates at 56%

How the call held up

The last pre-game call against the final score. Winner pre-game probability is how unexpected the result was.

The model favored PIT at 56%. Final: PIT 1–STL 5. The winner's pre-game probability was 44%.

pre-game call
PIT 56%
Final score
PIT 1–STL 5
Favored team
The favored team did not win
Winner's pre-game probability
44%

Simple alignment check: whether the team each factor favored won. This is not a causal claim.

  • Home Field Advantage favored PIT. Did not line up: STL won.
  • Defensive Efficiency was neutral — no side favored.
  • ELO Rating favored PIT. Did not line up: STL won.
  • Head to Head was neutral — no side favored.

Key factors

What's driving the win probability for this game

  • Home field favors Pittsburgh

    +3.0
  • Rest is even

    0
  • Weather impact is even

    0
  • Offensive efficiency is even

    0
  • Defensive efficiency is even

    0
  • Head to head is even

    0
Sign in to see factor scores, charts, and what-if simulations

What's driving this game

Each factor's contribution to the final win probability

STL
PIT

Home field

Home field favors Pittsburgh. +3.0 points.

Lime marks the side the model favors. STL is on the left, PIT on the right.

Premium feature: factor breakdown

Start 14-day free trial →

Understanding the win probability calculation

1 factor not shown (insufficient data)

Model version: 1.1.0 • Calculated:

Get the weekly slate

Each Monday: last week's report card and the week's closest games, with the factors behind them. Free, analytics only.

Key Players

Cardinals

Hunter DobbinsSP
Michael McGreevySP
Quinn MathewsSP
Kyle LeahySP
Andre PallanteSP

Pirates

Mitch KellerSP
Braxton AshcraftSP
Noah MurdockRP
Paul SkenesSP
Antwone KellyRP

Learn About Our Analysis

Learn about the factors behind our predictions

More games

Next and previous games for each team, plus others from this date. Win probabilities use the same display assessment as the game page.

Pittsburgh Pirates

St. Louis Cardinals

Other games on Sep 23, 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

Pirates has a 56% win probability, while Cardinals has a 44% win probability based on our analysis.

Our model considers weather conditions, offensive and defensive efficiency, rest days, injury impact, and historical performance.

This game is being played at PNC Park in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.

View all MLB games